|
Use of sacrificial Anodes for
external protection
Hulls of ships are very much prone to corrosion of an aggressive
nature in the form of pitting corrosion unless they are applied with
cathodic protection. Protection with the very best and the most
expensive coatings alone is not enough as the applied coating is
vulnerable to mechanical damage at sea or in port and to
imperfections at the time of application.
ETC has two main types of sacrificial anodes; high purity Zinc and
Aluminium which are alloyed with other metals to give performance
enhancement. Zinc was the first ever material to be used and is
therefore considered the traditional anode material. However,
Aluminium has several outstanding values and has fast become the
first anode of choice. Both Zinc and Aluminium anodes have a normal
design life of one, two or three years to suit the owner's
requirements. Hull anodes are usually welded direct to the ship
structure, but can be bolted if required.
The efficiency of any anode material depends upon its
electromechanical properties. First amongst these is open circuit
potential. For Aluminium, the open circuit potential is -1.0 volts
with reference to Ag/AgC1 reference electrodes whilst for Zinc it is
-1.05 volts. This translates to a better driving potential (voltage)
for Aluminium anodes which means that for the same anode
configuration, Aluminium anodes can deliver 30% more current than a
compatible Zinc anode system. Secondly, the current capacity of
Aluminium anodes is 2,500 Ampere-hours/Kg as compared to 780
Ampere-hours/kg for zinc anodes.
As an added benefit, fewer anodes translates into reduced frictional
resistance on the hull of the ship which reduces operation costs.
The higher the current capacity, the lower the consumption rate
becomes and hence the consumption rate for Aluminium is in the order
of 3.5 kg/Amp-year as compared to 11.23 Kg/Amp-Year for Zinc Anodes.
Thus Aluminium anodes with their higher electro-chemical capacity
and lower density, which translates into lesser weight and/or lesser
anodes than that of a Zinc system attracts tremendous economies
along with improved performance.
Number and Type of Anodes for Hull Protection
To obtain the approximate wetted hull area, the formula below may be
used.
(1.8 x LBP x D) + (BC x LBP x B) where LBP =Length between
perpendiculars. D=Draft. BC=Block coefficient. B=Breadth
|
Typical block coefficients for various vessels are: |
|
Tankers |
0.8 to 0.9 |
Naval vessels |
0.6 |
|
Dredgers
|
0.8 |
Tugs
|
0.6 |
|
Coasters |
0.75 |
Trawlers
|
0.55 |
|
Cargo vessels
|
0.75 |
Yatchs
|
0.4 to 0.5 |
|
Passenger Vessels |
0.6 |
Launchers |
0.4 |
The total current requirement is calculated as:
|
|
Current
(Amps) = |
Area (m2) x current density (mA/m2) |
|
1000 |
|
The total weight of
anode material is calculated as:
|
|
Number
of anodes
= |
Current (Amps)
x design life x 8760 |
|
capacity of material
(amps. hrs /kg) |
|
|
|
|
8760 = Number of hours in one year |
The number and type of anodes selected must satisfy both the total
current and total weight requirement as follows:
|
|
Number
of anodes
= |
Current required (Total) |
|
Individual anode
current output |
|
|
|
Number
of anodes
= |
Weight required (Total)
|
|
Individual anode net
weight |
|
Anode locations:
1. Full hull protection
Anodes should be located equidistantly as possible around the hull
between 4-6 meters apart. As a guide, 60 % of the calculated anodes
should be mounted in the after half of the vessel with further
consideration that 25% of the calculated anodes should be placed
around the stern only protection described below. Anodes situated in
the forward part of the vessel should be located to prevent damage
or removal by anchor chains.
2.Stern protection
Anodes should be positioned on the stern area and rudder adjacent to
the propeller; care being taken to minimize disturbance of the water
flow propeller. Anodes should not be fitted within 300mm of the line
of the propeller tips and should be parallel to the flow lines of
the hull. Twenty five percent of the anodes required for the hull
protection are required for stern only protection.
Use of Sacrificial Anodes for
Internal Cathodic Protection
The corrosion pattern in cargo ballast tanks of crude oil
carriers is very different from that on the ships hull but can prove
even more damaging and expensive. The cargo is alternated with sea
water and in this environment, the corrosion generally takes the
form of pitting on the horizontal surfaces such as the upper
stringer platforms, the inner bottom shell plating and the face
plates of longitudinal and transverse members.
Pitting corrosion almost certainly occurs in
lower areas where water may be present beneath oil cargoes and where
residual water is present in tanks which for all intensive purposes
are empty. ETC's pit-guard anodes are designed to prevent
pitting attacks on the bottom plating of cargo and ballast tanks.
Installed very close to the bottom plating, they provide the
necessary cathodic protection for the critical areas.
Because the residual water, remaining in the cargo/ ballast tanks
will most times be oily, the self cleaning property of ETC's Alinode
Aluminium alloy is definitely advantageous for this application.
Pit-guard are provided with an integral clamp for ease of attachment
to the scallop holes in the bottom longitudinal and can be fitted
during voyage.
However, it must be kept in mind that these anodes are relatively
small and may be permanently submerged in comparison to other anodes
in the same tank which are subject to ballasting factors. Periodic
inspection of the Pit-guard is recommended and replaced promptly
when ever necessary. The wastage of internal surfaces of "
permanent" ballast water tanks is usually uniform in nature and can
be inhibited by the installation of sacrificial anodes distributed
evenly throughout the internal surfaces.
Corrosion of these examples can be controlled simply and
economically with the installation of either Zinc or Aluminium
sacrificial anodes or a combination of both, depending on the
particular environmental conditions of each installation.
There is no restriction on the positioning of zinc anodes but it is
a recommended practice to ensure that the potential energy does not
exceed 540 kg-rn. Aluminium anodes are only permitted in cargo tanks
of tankers where the potential energy does not exceed 28 kg-rn. All
anodes should have mild steel inserts and these should be
sufficiently rigid to avoid resonance in the anode support and be
designed that they retain the anode when it is cast. The steel
inserts are generally attached to the structure by means of a
continuous weld. Anodes may alternatively be attached to the
structure by pre-welded supports or brackets by way of bolting with
a minimum of two nuts and bolts per anode.
Design and Installation of
sacrificial anodes for ships' internal tanks:
The system life should not be for less than
4 years utilizing an estimated ballast factor. Provision should be
made for additional anode consumption if it is anticipated that
residual ballast water will remain in the bottom of the tanks. The
resistivity of the ballast water will vary due to world wide
variations in climate. Generally, 25 ohm-cm is considered in
European and Scandinavian waters whilst 15- 20 oh for varm-cms would
be applicable in Middle and for Eastern waters. The system should be
designed accordingly.
Current densities applicable for various
tanks:
|
Cargo/clean ballast tanks |
86 mA/m2 |
|
Ballast only and Ballast
white oil cargo tanks |
108 mA/m2 |
| |
Upper wing tanks |
120 mA/ m2 |
| |
Fore and Aft peak tanks |
108 mA/m2 |
| |
Coated surfaces |
5 mA/m2 |
| |
Lower wing tanks |
86 mA/m2 |
| |
Double bottom tanks, ballast only
|
86 mA/m2 |
| |
Cargo/ Dirty ballast tanks |
Dependent on
trade |
Individual anode current output calculations:
Any anode output (ampere) is the difference in potential (voltage)
between the anode material and the steel structure polarised to
protection levels by the resistance (ohms) of the anode in the
electrolyte. This is expressed as:
I = E/R where I =Amperes, E = Volts, R =Ohms
Higher outputs from anodes are simply
associated with the cross section of the anode being a lot less than
the relationship to their length.
The type and number of anodes required:
The total current requirement is calculated as:
Current (Amps) = Protected Area (m2) x current density (mA/m2)
1000
The total weight of Anode material is calculated as:
Weight (kgs) = Current (Amps)
x design life x 8760
Capacity of material (Amp Hrs/Kg)
8760 = No of hours in one year
The number and type of anodes selected must satisfy both the current
and total weight requirement as follows:
Number of anodes =
Current required (Total)
individual anode current output
Number of anodes =
Weight required (Total)
Individual anode net weight
Resistance Calculation for Hull Anodes
For flat hull type anode the following formula can be used:
R = p
2 x s
Where p = Resistivity of water (ohms.cms). S = Arithmetic mean of
anode length and width
Resistance calculation for tank anodes
The resistance of slender tank anodes in an electrolyte can be
obtained by applying the following formulae:
R = P
2
∏
L
(
Ln 4 L - 1)
r
where R = Resisitivity of water (ohms cms.) L =Length of anode (cm)
p =Resistivity of water (ohms.cms) r -Mean effective radius of anode
(cms.) where R = ∫ Cross section Area
x
60
∏
100
INSPECTION
The cross sectional area of the anode to be used in determining the
mean effective radius is that corresponding to the anodes consumed
by 40%. This procedure is traditionally used in calculating anode
requirements in the marine industry as being indicative of anode
output during its life. ETC has a team of experienced
engineers available to inspect external and internal parts of any
vessel, and to advise on the most effective way of employing
cathodic protection to combat corrosion. Periodic inspection
of hull external surfaces and tank internals installed with cathodic
protection enables our engineers to confirm that existing systems
that are operating as intended, and/ or recommend improvements
that can be made to ensure that all surfaces are protected
efficiently and effectively until the next programmed dry docking
inspection.
TANK ANODE AND HULL ANODE INSTALLATION
ETC has an arrangement with a local Dubai based company that can
install tank anodes during ballast voyages using teams working from
rafts, divers or by abseiling. The diving team can also carry
out underwater inspection of the hulls of vessels, particularly when
the vessel is bunkering in local waters and if necessary,
sacrificial anodes can be welded in place under water.
PIPELINE PROTECTION
The pipeline used in larger tankers (i.e ballast lines, stripping
lines, cargo lines, etc) have given rise to substantial corrosion
problems. The control of external corrosion on pipelines can be
achieved by bonding each pipeline length to each other and to the
structure at reasonable intervals and as extra insurance, by adding
pipeline an ode bracelet assemblies at regular intervals. Effective
bonding of the lines is carried out without gas freeing the
internals of the lines. The system is installed by stud welding
brass studs to each section of the line, adjacent to each flexible
coupling and connected by removable if any coupling repair becomes
necessary. For an extra protection, anode bracelet assemblies
can be applied directly to the pipelines. Bonding of the bracelet
assembly to the pipeline is either by hardened steel earthing screws
or by studs being welded to both the pipeline and anode assembly.
TYPICAL ANODE FIXING METHODS

The above are standard
fittings which meet most requirements but special fittings will be
designed where necessary.
|